The following table uses 12 CFR 34.43, the OCC rule. Section 34.41 identifies its scope. Do not apply these numbers automatically to every lender, credit union, FHA or VA loan, or investor program.
Use transaction value. Under 34.42(o), a loan or extension of credit uses its amount. Sales and other listed property transactions use the market value of the interest involved. The asking price is not a universal substitute. In this framework, a residential transaction is secured by a single one-to-four-family residential property; “commercial” covers the other real estate-related financial transactions.
First: does an exception permit an evaluation?
Selected OCC appraisal exceptions that require an evaluation| OCC category and transaction value | Rule and result | Fact that changes the answer |
|---|
| Residential: $400,000 or less | Threshold exception in 34.43(a)(1); appropriate evaluation required by (b). | Exactly $400,000 qualifies for this exception. |
|---|
| Commercial: $500,000 or less | Threshold exception in 34.43(a)(13); appropriate evaluation required by (b). | Exactly $500,000 qualifies for this exception. |
|---|
| Qualifying business loan: $1 million or less | Exception in (a)(5) only if repayment is not primarily dependent on sale of, or rental income from, real estate; evaluation required. | A business borrower alone does not satisfy the repayment condition. |
|---|
Then: if an appraisal is required, must the appraiser be certified?
OCC state-certified appraiser requirements after exceptions are checked| Federally related transaction | Certification rule | Boundary to keep |
|---|
| Federally related transaction: $1 million or more | State-certified appraiser required by (d)(1). | Apply transaction exceptions first. This is not a rule requiring an appraisal for every $1 million loan. |
|---|
| Commercial federally related transaction: over $500,000 | State-certified appraiser required by (d)(2). | The commercial certification rule starts above $500,000. |
|---|
| Complex residential federally related appraisal: over $400,000 | State-certified appraiser required by (d)(3). | Atypical property, ownership or market conditions can make it complex. The institution makes the final determination. |
|---|
Check exceptions before certification. Under 34.42(g), a federally related transaction is a covered real estate-related financial transaction that requires an appraiser. For example, a qualifying business loan of exactly $1 million can be exempt. A nonexempt federally related transaction of exactly $1 million requires certification. The amount alone does not decide which rule applies.
Below the threshold does not mean no valuation
Section 34.43(b) requires an appropriate evaluation for the listed threshold and qualifying business-loan exceptions. The OCC can also require an appraisal for safety and soundness. Other applicable program, investor or lender requirements may still call for an appraisal.
Section 34.43 includes other exceptions, including specified existing-credit and government or government-sponsored transactions. Their conditions and the applicable program's own requirements matter. Being outside an OCC appraisal requirement is not a universal waiver.